Well, Toronto was supposed to suck this year, and Cavs were supposed to be the 8th seed. At the end of the season raps are sitting at the 3rd seed while Cavs are in the lottery. DeMar overachieved while Kyrie underachieved big time. Plus DeMar is more durable and plays more defense than Kyrie.
But yeah I'd trade DeMar for Irving if we didn't have lowry.